Mr Maulana Salman Husaini Nadwi & Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Anti-Venom ( Phakki )

( Apparently you look like maligning Sahaba Of Prophet Muhammad .” Neo – Khawarijism” )

Sheikh Mubashir , Afaq Malik , Gabriel Iqbal , Mudasir Al-Majdey Mushtaq Ul-Haq Ahmad Sikander , Bilal Bashir Bhat

1) Quran says about Sahaba :
رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُمْ وَرَضُوا عَنْهُ
“Allah is pleased with them and they with Him”

• Are you suggesting me ,a zunni data ,which was compiled compiled 270 years after Prophet and exgesis tafsir (which came 300 after Quran) can abrogate the creed( Aqeedah) of quran .
  No way – I accept hadith or tafseer as long it doesn’t contradicts Quran – No matter it’s in Bukhari or in Usul kafi , Tabari or in Al-Meezan , Ibn Ishaq or in Abu Mikhnafs ” Al- Maqtal or in Arabian nights or in Persian Fantasies .

2) I reject any Nasibi or Zakiri theories which contradict Quran and Hadith ( that Hadith only in agreement WID✓ quran) .The only source of Islam is “Quran & Sahi Hadith” .

3) Sahi Hadith : Gentlemen ,there was only one defition of sahi Hadith ,prior to Khateeb Baghdadi ,which came 500 years after era of Sahaba ,

A) ” HADITH is “SAHI” only when its matn is in agreement with Quran .Even word Tawattur ، came into being in evolution of hadith science ,after Kahateeb Baghdadis era ( 500 years after Quran ) – Tawattur is a simple transporting carrier of data ( Hadith) – it does not authenticate hadith as Wahi ( Parralel to quran ) rather it makes the Hadith (Data of information) available to us as secondary source of information .

B) The categorisation of hadith Into Sahi ,Sahi ligayriya ,Hassan ,Hassan ligayriya ,mashhoor ,aziz ,mawdhu based on systematic system of Mutasil,Adill of raawi ,Zabt of raawi,Shaaz ,Makhfi ul illat and rest is recent categorization in the science of hadith and certiantly it’s most sophisticated system ,full proof system in the entire history of academics but the basic rule which supersede them all is ” “”Matn of hadith should not contradict creed of Quran “

3) Gentlemen ! I am not telling you a new thing – This was basic maxim of usool e Hadith since the time of Imam jaffar ,Abu Hanifa and imam Malik – But this maxim was in theory but later usooleen never applied it in totality ( it was theoritical part not applied part )

4) Quran tells me ( Surah Al- Imran : 10 ) ” ohh sahaba you are best of generation “
But your fantasies of Tabari & Abu Mikhnafs tells me ,More than 90000 sahabas were killed in mutual fight for Politicle power. No way ..

A) You tell me ? Can the generation of sahabas trained by prophet sas fight for this political power , Rasoolah sas came to establish Tawheed he didn’t came to establish world power – R u suggesting ,these sahabas were immature maaz Allah ( may God forbid ) .Either you accept Quran ” which call them best or you opt for ibn Saba’s Persian fantasies or arabian night stories .

5) Stories of Bible : Prophet Muhammad sas is prophet from Aalum e Arwah ( before begining of physical life ) ,read Quran (Surah Araf : 172 )
When thy Lord drew forth,From the Children of Adam ,from their loins—their descendants, and made them,Testify concerning themselves, (saying):
“Am I not your Lord
(Who cherishes and sustains you)?”—
They said: “Yea!
We do testify!”

A) ?? Are you suggesting me ,Prophet needs Biblical scholar ,Warqah bin Nafil to testify him that he was a prophet ???,no way –

B) Gibrael did not came with ibhham ,he came with a clear message of Allah – Prophet was knowing ,This is Gibrael , messenger of Allah ,why will he need a biblical scholar to tell him that he is a prophet .
Infact Prophet scolded Caliph Omer for even reading bible when Quran was already present .

6) Abu bakr Alihimusalam :
A) Person, who was shadow of prophet before his death and became prophets shadow even after his death sharing same grave yard in the small bedroom of prophet ,

B) when prophet told him ohh Abu bakr ,what you left back home – he replied ,Ya Rasoolullah sas I left name of Allah and his Rasool back home

C) Person ,who prefer stings of scorpion in
Garri e suorr ,over disturbing the sleep of prophets ,when he was in pain ,tears rolled out his eyes ,gazing the face of Rasoolullah was preferred by him over his death – when tear struck the face of Rasoolullah ,he said ohh
Abu bakr sideeq ,Abu bakr replied (” qurbani leghnhez myoun mol ti mouj Ya Rasoolullah ” )
O Messenger of Allah! May my father and mother be sacrificed for you!”

D) I am told ,That Abu bakr left the burial arrangements of prophet along with omer for three days ,so that he will take part in meeting of Banu saqeefa to become a Caliph – No way I will not accept this Persian story – Abu bakr was the person who preferred death over a single gaze of Prophet Muhammad sas ,how can he leave prophet Muhammad after his death –

E) Prophet had already told them ohh sahaba
” Don’t delay the burial of deceased “
I am told by exegesist of persia ,that Abu bakr and Umar delayed the burial for three days ,how is that possible ,that too in humid condition of madina.

3) Caliph Omer :
-A) He is the person ,whom prophet said
Ohh sahaba ,”If there were to be a Prophet after me, it would be ‘Umar”
B) Ohh sahaba ” Devil fear omer “
C) During famine ,omer saw apple 🍎 in the hands of his hungry son ,he ran after him and said omer son cannot eat what my people can’t effort .
-D) Omer was the person ,who said ,on dooms day ,I will be asked if a goats leg gets struck in the broken plank of wooden bridge made in my era .
E) “”” Gentlemen ! I am told ,that prophet was about to write name of next Caliph ,he told Omer to fetch him pen and paper ( Qirtaas) but omer rejected his order ,may God forbid .
Signifying (,they allege) ,prophet would have written his will for next Caliph ,but omer did not let him do so . Astagfirullah

F) Prophet prophesied even minutest details till dooms – how he missed to name Mawla Ali to be next Caliph for 23 years –

G) Infact choosing Caliph is not job of Prophet sas rather it’s job of Shurah :
Quran says ” Amruhum Shura Baynahum” (42:38) Quran demands that even the head of an Islamic State be appointed through consultation; the system itself be based on consultation; everyone should have an equal right in consultation;
The state affairs ( Caliphate) is one of the most crucial affairs for which shura (consultation) is required in accordance to the Qur’an.

H) Also note that the verse 42:38 is not specifically addressing the Muslims in Mecca at the time of the prophet (pbuh). It is a general verse addressing all Muslims. Even today ,no clergy ,no leader ,no wali or no imam has right thrust leadership on Muslim it’s only shurah

4) Mawla Ali under the caliphate of Shaikhain :
A) Who was Ali – Ali was cousin of Prophet but he was bought up in the house of Rasoolullah sas after the death of father Abu talib ,he was like adopted son Prophet sas

B) He was person who accompanied his fatherly figure Rasoolullah in every war he fought ( exception is tabook as per their data )

C) He was the person ,to whom prophet bestowed his most beloved daughter Fatima .

• He was father of Ainan of Prophet ( Hassan & Hussain)
  D) Are you suggesting me ,that brave solider of Rasool ul lah sas could have accepted 24 year old rule of Shaikhain & Uthuman – had it been rule of tyranny – Mawla would never had accepted it –
  Household of Prophet can’t accept wrong rulership .Mawla Ali accepted the decision of Shurah of Sahaba and served Muslim ummah under the pious caliphate of Abu bakr ,omer and Uthuman .

E) Caliphate is not meant for any tribe or caste ,islam came to destroy caste system ,any one can became ruler according to quran if shurah choose black slave of africa over Quresh of Arab – no one has right to deny his right to rule .

F) I have not seen any one in 23 countries of the Arab world with caste of Syed . ” Syed ” was not even caste in entire history of kashmir aswell – But now every one call himself to be Syed mutilating & replacing their honoured caste of baba ,safaid posh ,mallas and what not .Every human being has same progeny Adam & eve .Abu jahl was a Quresh & Bilal was african slave .

G ) Quran say : Rasoolullah sas said Arab had no superiority over non Arab ,white has no superiority over black and vice versa – The best among among you are those who are more God concious (serving the humanity irrespective of creed ,aborginality and colour)

5) Uthuman : ” Usman du Noorain” – Alihimusalam
A) Can you imagen about a person

• Your daughter ( kids ) are part of you – like wise daughters of Prophet sas were blood flesh of their father ,

B) Prophet Muhammad sas gave his two daughter in the nikkah of Uthuman – that is reason he is known as possessor of two lights( Du- Noorain ) of Rasoolullah .

C) Once prophet was told by sahaba ,why you fold your legs and cover your thighs when you hear Usman is on his way to meet you ,he replied – ohh sahaba ,I have heard foot step of Uthuman in jannah .

D) False Accusations Against Uthman by Persian historian :
Now ,I am told by Persian scholar including Abu mikhnaf that Usman was not fair – he prefferred his own relative for adminstrator jobs rather than other .
May Allahs mercy on Abu Ala mawdudi ,he has copy pasted wholesale from this superstitious Persian fantasies in his book ” Khilaafat ya malookiyat ” which has inflicted and inspired modern day scholars like sulaiman Nadwi ,Moulana ishaaq jehlemi and now Engineer Ali Mirza , Hafizhummulah .

E) Don’t we feel shame ,a person whom Allah told ohh Uthuman I am pleased with you and prophet Muhammad said to him you are so pious even if I had more daughters ,I would have married them to you – and we are maligning same sahaba .

F) He was a multi millionaire of his time ,but he never recruited any security guard for him so as to secure himself from khawarijis .

6) Mawla Ali Alihimusalam :
Can we imam mawiya be compared with the status of Mawla Ali Alihimusalam – No way .

A) Ali is the person ,whose father & guardian was Rasoolullah after the death of Abu talib .

B) He was the first person to accept islam ( I can’t allege it’s nasibiyat of imam shibli but I can say it’s weird to say categories the first moomineen – )

C) Fidaaka Ya Ameer ul moomineen Ali :
Ali was the person ,for whom prophet coax to persuade him if he gets upset or sulk away for overburden family affairs – Prophet used to look for him – he used to ask sahabas have you seen my son Ali ,Once he found ali on the sleeping on dusty ground and called upon
” Ya Abaa Taraab “
Oh you father of dust
(May my parents be sacrificed be sacrificed for both Rasoolullah sas and Mawla Ali )

D) Now These nasibis are treading a new biddah ,on the day of qarbala ,they convene
” jalsa e Yazeed” on the same day of muharam when heart of Prophet Imam Hussain Alihimusalam was sacrifice – they add suffix Rahmatullah to yazid .on contrary their counter zakiries try to alleviate Mawla Ali to level of God .

7) Mother of Believers Aisha Alihimusalam :
(The most targeted Ahli-bayt by sabaiees )

A) Nikkah of Aisha was a divine command : Angel Gabriel came to Prophet Muhammad carrying a green silk cloth with her image on it and said “this is your wife in this world and in the hereafter”.

B) This was divine command ,that prophet married 19 year old Aisha – it was not mere co-incidence – it was part of divine plan – and we owe to this pious lady ,that she secured most of data relating to islam ( 2nd most)

C ) She was the lady ,who used to mend hair of our prophet ,groom his dailies with love ,and she had the previledge ,in whose lap prophet sas expired before brushing teeth with siwaak semi chewed by Aisha thus the last thing which prophet sas recieved was saliva of Aisha .

D) Now Sabaiees are telling me , giving me Persian fantasies to malign my mother even I don’t gather courage to narrate other wierd accusation .

8) Gentlemen ! target is not Yazeed, ,target is every sahaba starting from Abu- bakr.
Target is to replace Quran by fantasies of superstitious lineage system .

9)Note : ” Am I correct” : No way , I can be wrong aswell – if my narrative contradicts creed of Quran and then sahi Hadith –

10) is this blog for every one and fully explained : No ,those who are not well versed with science of hadith must not troll in ,narrative in blog is not fully explained ,academic discussion cant be explained fully on social media – nor I believe I am fully correct rather this is part of academic discourse and I am ready to stand corrected .
Any one has right to disagree ,call me to do my islah .

“only source of Islam is Quran and Sahi Hadith ” our Hujjah are not Arab or Persian scholars but Quran and Sunnah .

Dr Ashraf Kashmiri
drashrafshafikashmiri@gmail.com

• WordPress